A harbor of quaint beach towns outlined with miles of soft, sandy beaches along Lake Michigan. Coastal towns such as New Buffalo, Sawyer, Three Oaks, Union Pier, Michiana and Harbert attract many vacationers throughout the year. Beyond the beach, discover local vineyards, wineries, breweries, U-pick farms, and the extensive culinary options around every corner. Nature is also at your fingertips with an abundance of parks, estuaries, hiking trails, forests, and sand dunes. The opportunities to enjoy the best of the Southwest Michigan shoreline are endless.
ABOUT us
The staff of Toni Stay’s are specialists in the rental of high-quality vacation properties in the general vicinity of New Buffalo and Union Pier Michigan. It is our passion to provide guests with a quality home along with excellent service that will ensure a memory making stay. Quality is not only the luxury of our vacation home rentals that we personally visit and inspect. For us, luxury is also the high quality of the vacation experience of our guests.
RENTAL PROPERTIES
Birds Nest • New Buffalo, MI
The Birds Nest in New Buffalo welcomes you to four levels of fun. Featuring a private heated swimming pool, hot tub, association beach, pool table, foosball table, screened porch, balcony & dog friendly!
2023 Renovations include the refreshed primary bathroom & addition of pool table, and 60" smart TV.
Located in the New Buffalo neighborhood of Sturgeon Beach to easily reach the best of New Buffalo & Union Pier by bike or car. Wedged between the sandy shore of Lake Michigan & the Galien River.
4 Bedrooms + Loft
3 Kings • 3 Twins • 1 Bunk Bed
​
3 Full Baths
1 Half Bath
​
Maximum Guests : 11
​
​
Association Beach
Private Heated Pool
Private Hot Tub
Lily's Paradise • Union Pier, MI
4 Bedrooms
1 King • 2 Queens • 2 Twins
​
2 Full Baths
1 Half Bath
​
Maximum Guests : 8
​
​
Lakefront
Private Beach
Large Deck
Large Yard
Welcome to Lily's Paradise, a dreamy, classic Lake Michigan cottage where lake breezes, moonlit nights, and sand-between-your-toes living are included. With four bedroom, beautiful details, and cozy common spaces, this home is all about laid-back luxury. Whether you're gazing at the beach over a cup of coffee, roasting marshmallows on the beach under the stars, or tossing beanbags with your crew, this is lakeside living.
Cherry Beach Pool House • Harbert, MI
Welcome to Cherry Beach Pool House. A beautifully renovated home with amenities that will entertain your group any time of year. Enjoy the 101 degree hot tub, wood burning firepit, wood burning fireplace and fenced yard. Late May to September 30 float in the heated pool and soak in the outdoor shower. Your whole group + fido will enjoy home time as much as Cherry Beach time!
4 Bedrooms
3 Kings • 2 Twins • 1 Bunk
​
3 Full Baths
1 Half Bath
​
Maximum Guests : 11
​
​
Private Heated Pool
Private Hot Tub
Fenced Yard
Screen Porch
Creekside Fun • Michiana, MI
Year Round Swim Spa, Red Light Sauna, Fire Pit, Game Room...the amenities make this a fantastic gathering spot ANY time of year. Two ensuite bedrooms on the 2nd floor, two bedrooms with hall bathrooms on the main and lower level. Main floor has a massive great room with spacious kitchen, dining table & conversation spot by the fireplace. Lower level has a sectional, the sauna and a 50" TV for game time. The game room is the designated kids spot with shuffle board, 55" TV and room to hang!
6 Bedrooms
2 Kings • 2 Queens • 3 Twins
1 Double
​
4 Full Baths
1 Half Bath
​
Maximum Guests : 12
​
​
Large Screened Porch
18 x 8’ Swim Spa
Infared Sauna
Wood Burning Firepit
Family Tide Pool House • Union Pier, MI
Year Round Swim Spa, Red Light Sauna, Fire Pit, Game Room...the amenities make this a fantastic gathering spot ANY time of year. Two ensuite bedrooms on the 2nd floor, two bedrooms with hall bathrooms on the main and lower level. Main floor has a massive great room with spacious kitchen, dining table & conversation spot by the fireplace. Lower level has a sectional, the sauna and a 50" TV for game time. The game room is the designated kids spot with shuffle board, 55" TV and room to hang!
4 Bedrooms
2 Kings • 2 Queens • 2 Twins
​
3 Full Baths​
Maximum Guests : 10
​
​
Private Heated Pool
One Acre Lot
Four Public Beaches Nearby
Outdoor Fire Pit
